New Construction vs. Remodel Recessed Lighting: Choosing the Right Housing
So, you've decided to upgrade your home's lighting with sleek, modern recessed lighting. It's a fantastic choice for creating clean sightlines and providing ample illumination. But as you start shopping, you'll quickly encounter a critical decision: do you need a "new construction" or "remodel" housing? Understanding this difference is the most important step to a successful installation.
Let's break down these two types of housings to ensure your lighting project goes off without a hitch.
The Core Difference: Access to the Ceiling
The fundamental difference between new construction and remodel housings boils down to one thing: the state of your ceiling.
-
New Construction Housings: These are designed for installations where the ceiling drywall is not yet in place. You have open, easy access to the joists.
-
Remodel Housings: These are designed for existing ceilings where you want to add new lights without creating a massive mess. The drywall is already up, and access is limited to the small hole you cut for the light itself.
New Construction Housings: Building from the Ground Up
As the name implies, these are meant for brand-new builds, major additions, or rooms where the entire ceiling is being ripped down to the joists.
-
Key Feature: They have long, sturdy metal arms that fasten directly to the ceiling joists. This provides a incredibly strong and secure foundation for the housing.
-
When to Use Them:
-
Building a new home or addition.
-
Finishing a basement or attic from scratch.
-
Completely replacing an old, damaged ceiling.
-
-
Pros: Extremely robust installation, often more affordable than remodel housings.
-
Cons: Absolutely require open access to joists; impossible to install in a finished ceiling.
Remodel Housings: The Magic of Retrofitting
This is where the term retrofit recessed lights truly comes into play. Remodel housings are the go-to solution for updating your lighting without major renovation.
-
Key Feature: They are secured to the existing drywall itself, not the joists. They feature adjustable, spring-loaded clips or squeeze clamps that tighten against the back of the drywall, holding the can firmly in place.
-
When to Use Them:
-
Adding recessed lighting to an existing room.
-
Replacing old, inefficient "can" lights with modern LED units.
-
Any project where you want to avoid tearing open the entire ceiling.
-
-
Pros: Perfect for renovations, much less invasive and messy.
-
Cons: Generally slightly more expensive than new construction housings due to their specialized mounting mechanisms.
The Modern Alternative: Canless Recessed Lights
In recent years, a third option has revolutionized the recessed lighting game: canless recessed lights, or "wafer" LEDs. These are all-in-one units that combine the LED, driver, and housing into a single, very thin module.
-
How They Fit In: Canless lights are almost always installed like a remodel housing. They require only a small hole and are held in place by spring clips against the drywall. Their ultra-thin profile allows them to fit into shallow ceiling cavities where traditional "cans" cannot.
-
Big Advantage: They eliminate the need for a separate metal can and they are incredibly easy to install. They are the ultimate retrofit recessed lights.
-
Consideration: Because they are an all-in-one unit, if the LED fails years down the line, you replace the entire unit, not just a bulb. However, with their long lifespans (often 50,000+ hours), this is less of a concern.
Which One Should You Choose?
-
Do you see exposed joists? -> Use New Construction Housings.
-
Do you see finished drywall? -> Use Remodel Housings or Canless Recessed Lights.
Pro Tip: Always check the IC (Insulation Contact) rating. If your lights will be in a ceiling with insulation (like an attic), you must use an "IC-Rated" housing to prevent fire hazards. Both new construction and remodel housings come in IC and non-IC versions.
Understanding this key difference will save you time, money, and a huge headache. Whether you choose a traditional can-based system or a modern canless solution, picking the right housing is the key to a bright and beautiful outcome. Happy installing
